[Michlib-l] ARC Responses
chimp1cards at gmail.com
Thu Jun 29 19:56:43 EDT 2017
I spoke with a friend from Harper Collins a couple years ago. They also
say after the publishing date, the book can be offered for sale.
Kent District Library
East Grand Rapids branch
On Thu, Jun 29, 2017 at 7:18 PM Sheryl Mase <smase at mmll.org> wrote:
> I just had a conversation with the staff person in Horizon books in
> Cadillac (their main store is in Traverse City) because when I stepped in
> to the vestibule, they had a cart of advance reader copy books for sale.
> The staff member told me that they may say "not for sale" but they sell
> them anyway. I pushed back and she contacted their home office and was told
> that the publishers say it's OK after the date of publication. I am not a
> lawyer, I haven't spoken to one and I have no idea if that's correct. But
> if bookstores can sell them after the date of publication I would think
> that libraries could sell them in their book sales. However, I do think
> it's unethical personally...and would not add them to the collection.
> Sheryl L. Mase, Director
> Mid-Michigan Library League
> 201 N. Mitchell, Suite 302, Cadillac MI 49601
> phone: 231-775-3037 email: smase at mmll.org
> http://mmll.org <http://mmll.org/>~ visit us on facebook
> On Jun 28, 2017, at 5:48 PM, Sharon Crotser-Toy <scrotsertoy at gmail.com>
> Brace yourself for an especially lengthy collection of responses!
> Thank you to everyone for your quick (and illuminating) responses to my
> question about ARCs! Here they are, compiled, as requested by a couple of
> Once I've read the ARC's I usually put them in the little free libraries
> that we stock here in Grandville. I have also used them as giveaways during
> school visits. From my understanding, you cannot make ARC's part of a
> library collection. They are not finished copies and the ARC copies usually
> say explicitly on them that they cannot be sold or used in library
> collections. I love getting them in kids hands and try to do that as much
> as possible.
> I believe you are not supposed to put these items on your shelves, or that
> what I was taught way back before I became a Director. I always just bring
> stuff back for the staff to divide among themselves, or maybe offer as
> little door prizes at programs.
> These ARCs are for personal use and cannot be sold or added to a Library's
> We often hand them out as raffle prizes at the beginning of programs or
> pass them around to staff members.
> May not be sold, should not be cataloged. They are NOT final proofread
> We have just started doing facebook giveaways. Be the first person to
> find the right answer about our web page and you win.
> I also take giant bags to a big family reunion (Sunday in Cadillac!) and
> they all get taken.
> We have the summer reading program and we use them as prizes. As for the
> extra, we give them to staff who wants them, then we also have little
> libraries for the community. Basically we can drop books off in here and
> people can take them home for free (usually leave the slip in there that
> asks them to go online and review since it is an arc).
> We have a spot by our biggby that goes empty all the time because college
> students and kids snatch them up in the area.
> I don't think you are allowed to circulate them. I don't think it's
> "illegal" but it's unethical. You weren't given them to get out of
> supporting the author. (that is how I have explained it to my teachers who
> sometimes get ARC's). I give them away as freebies or prizes. But I also
> read a lot of them and then review them because the authors and publishers
> are looking for early buzz. Your library staff can help review as well and
> then if the books are good, buy them for your library.
> We just put them on a “Free” shelf for patrons to take.
> I was always under the impression that circulating ARCs was a no-no, for a
> few reasons: the manuscript could change significantly upon publication,
> copyright issues, and the ambiguous release date. I'd be interested in
> hearing if libraries do add them to the collection. I don't add them at
> Sharon, arcs are never allowed to be put on library shelves or to be sold
> by Friends Group. There was just a big discussion about this issue on
> Twitter. Putting arcs on shelves is taking profit out of author's pockets
> and they (authors) are rethinking the entire arc giveaways.
> I've run a pre-pub book club for years. Was written up in Shelf Awareness.
> 1 of rules that I MUST legally abide by is to not sell, or put in
> So, we give them away as prizes, put in Little Free Library's, shelters
> As far as my libraries, I am new here, but I believe that the previous
> director used them for giveaways (sometimes with little notes attached
> noting they were ARCs and to feel free to review the book for the publisher
> and/or let the library know if it is a book they feel we need to purchase).
> I don't think ARCs are permitted to circulate, but I admit I also don't
> We did have a great idea from a former teen librarian (could also work for
> all ages): she put them at a service desk (honor system) and asked patrons
> to read and review them, then if the review was good and she bought the
> book, she promoted it with that review.
> Since most of these are stamped "not for resale," I have always assumed
> that they were neither eligible to pass along to Friends groups or to put
> in the collection. They are provided to prep sellers/librarians, boost
> sales, contain a variety of missed edits and don't truly represent the
> author's final product. I don't believe there is any bib data for these.
> Since these were giveaways at ALA, you probably have more leeway, but if
> you make this a practice, your library might get cut out of any formalized
> programs through publishers or wholesalers if they find out. Unlikely, but
> a risk. While it seems a waste of resources, I have always recycled these
> or passed them to other libraries/staff members when finished.
> We put ARCs on a freebie table.
> For YA ARCs, I give them to our teen volunteers as prizes or thank yous.
> We do not add them to our collection.
> We do not catalog ARC's, nor from everything I've read is it legal to do
> so. You may get a waiver from an author or publisher allowing you to
> circulate it, but if so I would keep that waiver on file.
> We offer ARC's around to staff first, for review purposes, then we offer
> them to members of the Friends of the Library, and then we just put them
> out for the public with a sign that clearly states they are advance review
> copies and cannot be legally sold or resold with a recommendation that if
> the person reading the book likes it they post a review somewhere and pass
> it on to a friend.
> We used to keep boxes of ARC's back for Christmas and distribute them
> during a local parade; we also have put them out for free during our
> holiday Open House (with the aforementioned sign), but we haven't done any
> programming specifically around ARC's.
> My understanding is that ARCs are expressly not to be added to library
> collections, but I don’t know if that’s a policy thing from places I’ve
> worked or a permission-from-publishers thing that’s more universal.
> Sharon - most of the publishers do not allow circulation of ARCS, but do
> allow giveaway. We have a rep at BT who explained to us what we can and
> cannot do. Because they are not published yet and may contain errors, and
> are available before publication and street date, they should not be
> circulated. They cannot be sold either, so they don't go to our friends
> We give some away at teen events and some go to local little free library
> organizations. We allow staff to take and read them and return them or pass
> them to friends.
> We use ARCs that we bring back from conferences as summer reading prizes.
> Since most libraries have adult summer reading too, that solution works for
> all of them.
> At the East Lansing Public Library, we give them away as prizes for our
> summer reading programs or at other programs. I am not sure you can
> actually catalog and put them on your shelves. I know you cannot sell them
> in the Friends used books or any other way.
> We were always told that we can't sell them and we can't add them. That
> was the deal with getting ARCs. So we use them as grab-bag prizes for
> summer reading prizes. We run a reading=>tickets/entries into drawings for
> specific prizes. For the grab bags, we get as many of the cool bags and
> ARCs that we can at the conference or from the local book store, and group
> them into like genres (romance, mystery, general fiction, true crime (if we
> get enough), teen, etc.). Participants only see the bag, the genre, and
> how many books are in the bag. It's pretty popular here as a prize.
> I would closely read any copyright or disclaimers that appear on the books
> themselves – different publishers may have different requirements on how
> ARCs can be used.
> I also located a couple of other sources that discuss ARCs.
> Here is an interesting Blog entry on the topic:
> Here is how one library deals with them (that appears to be completely
> within the scope of an ARC’s purpose):
> Sorry if someone has already said this, but ARC are NOT supposed to go on
> library shelves. They have not yet been fully edited and CANNOT and MAY NOT
> be sited. Please do not place these on your shelves. The errors I have
> in some that I have read are horrendous!
> All those lovely ARCs! This is the first program I’ve done to try to
> put them to good use, and I was very pleased with how it turned out:
> - Distributed ARC’s to readers via programs or word of mouth
> - Stipulated that readers must read the book, write a review, and
> have their photo taken with the book for publication via Facebook/the
> - Those who participated were given a coupon for a free drink at
> the local coffee shop
> We distributed the reviews and photos via Facebook, mostly. When I
> ordered in the “real” books, I re-shared the Facebook posts as further
> publicity for that book.
> You can look up the photos and reviews on our Facebook page, here:
> p.s. If patrons ask, I tell them they may pass the ARC on to someone else
> who would enjoy it. Otherwise, they go on the Friends of the Library book
> They make good Summer Reading give-aways.
> We do not put them on our shelves OR sell them in our used bookstore.
> We give them away as freebies to the library staff and volunteers. I think
> we gave them away also once for our Senior bingo game. So in recent years I
> have searched out the “real” books when I go to conferences unless I know
> someone on staff will want to read the ARC.
> We put them in the staff break room as freebies/job perks and encourage
> people to read and, if appropriate, review them. We tell them that even if
> it's not for them, but for a friend, neighbor, or family member, to please
> find someone by whom it will be appreciated. We've never put them into
> circulation but I have seen many libraries that have a special shelving
> unit for ARCs that patrons can take.
> SPEAKING OF ARCs -- I tried desperately to extend my trip through Monday
> in order to see Andy Weir and get a copy of Artemis for our librarian who
> buys science fiction. Did any of you, by chance, end up with an extra copy
> you would gift to someone who would be, oh, so grateful? [Rudy C. Wright,
> Adult Services, Portage District Library, 300 Library Lane, Portage, MI
> 49002 269-329-4544 ext. 8713]
> Any ARC's that I get I use as prizes. I do not think they belong on the
> shelf because they aren't the final finished product in most cases. I have
> encouraged kids to pass them on to a friend and many times place a library
> sticker inside that says courtesy of so they don't forget they got it from
> I strongly second what Carol said. ARCs are for promotional and review
> purposes ONLY, and are not to be used in the place of fully edited and
> published copies!
> We do a display on our shelves (ours is by the holds in our new section).
> We put a spine label on them but no barcode. It's an honor system and
> patrons typically tell us they are taking them as they think it's a check
> out item and we keep a tally and consider it a program. I am going to take
> a few of the ones from ALA - The Last Mrs. Parrish and Need to Know(which
> is going to be a movie) and offer to our book club.
> The patrons do like them and it's good PR in a small town because they
> knew we went. Whatever you decide, keep it simple!
> Sharon Crotser-Toy
> *Watervliet District Library*
> 333 N. Main Street
> Watervliet, MI 49098
> Connects People, Inspires Ideas, Transforms Lives
> Michlib-l mailing list
> Michlib-l at mcls.org
> Michlib-l mailing list
> Michlib-l at mcls.org
Galatians 5:22-6:10 (with some creative control)
The harvest of the Spirit is love, joy, peace, patience, kindness,
goodness, fidelity, gentleness, and self-control.....so let us never tire
of doing good, for if we do not slacken our efforts we shall in due time
reap our harvest. Therefore, as opportunity offers, let us work for the
good of all....
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
More information about the Michlib-l